English Language
Lyric Analysis
He could be a sinner, or a gentleman
He could be a preacher when your soul is damned
He could be a lawyer on a witness stand
But he'll never love you like I can, can
He could be a stranger you gave a second glance
He could be a trophy of a one night stand
He could have your humor, but I don't understand
'Cause he'll never love you like I can, can, can
Why are you looking down all the wrong roads?
When mine is the heart and the salt of the soul
there may be lovers who hold out their hands
But they'll never love you like I can, can, can
they’ll never love you like I can, can
He could be a preacher when your soul is damned
He could be a lawyer on a witness stand
But he'll never love you like I can, can
He could be a stranger you gave a second glance
He could be a trophy of a one night stand
He could have your humor, but I don't understand
'Cause he'll never love you like I can, can, can
Why are you looking down all the wrong roads?
When mine is the heart and the salt of the soul
there may be lovers who hold out their hands
But they'll never love you like I can, can, can
they’ll never love you like I can, can
In this song, the writer has used a large amount of
metaphors to get his message across to the person who the song was aimed at. ‘Preacher
when your soul is damned’, ‘could be a lawyer on a witness stand’. These
metaphors are put in the show that, although the other person she loves could be
the most supportive person and help her through hard times, they’ll never be
loved more than the writer could love them. Although he isn’t saying this
directly, it is made obvious in his choice of words that he feels this way.
Lawyers are very well respected people who hold a lot of power in making
decisions to help people’s lives, so in a way, the writer is saying that
although the other man could completely change her life and give her want she
wants, he can give her more love. The use of the word ‘dammed’ when referring
to her soul created a very dark image in the audiences head, almost as if she’s
committed a sin. This reinforces how much that he loves her as although she has
made mistakes and needs the help of a preacher to clear her ‘dammed soul’ he
still loves her regardless.
The write sings, ‘he could be your trophy of a one night
stand’. This is the writer trying to say that the other person isn’t necessarily
with her for the right reasons. It seems that he is trying to insinuate that he
is with her for sex whereas he is deeply in love with her. He is saying that
the current man she is with just reminds of her this and the fact that there
are no feelings in comparison to what the singer has with her.
In the chorus, the lyrics are, ‘Why are you looking down
all the wrong roads? When mine is the heart and the salt of the soul, there may
be lovers who hold out their hands, But they'll never love you like I can, can,
can, they’ll never love you like I can, can’. The singer is asking why the receiver
is unable to see that he is clearly the right choice of person for her. The chorus
sort of seems to have a religious view behind it. ‘mine is the heart and the
salt of the soul’, he’s saying that his love is the basic foundation of her
life and that her soul will be, as mentioned before, ‘dammed’ without his love.
He also makes reference to the other people that would just ‘hold out their
hands’ for her. This created the mental imagery of people praying on their
knees for her love. This may be used to try to get across the message that the
other people need her whereas she needs the writers love. The word ‘can’ is
repeated over and over to reinforce the fact that he can love her like she
wants to be loved and the fact that he can love her this much. In my head, this
use of repetition linked with the previous line creates the idea of people preaching
something which may have been the intention of the writer to have people
preaching and agreeing with what he is saying to reinforce his point.
I agree with your comments on this song.In the part where its says 'He could be a sinner, or a gentleman' the contrast between a negative word such as sinner and then a positive word like gentleman shows the extent of his love. The opposites show that no matter who they may be there is no one at all who an love them as much as he can.
ReplyDeleteI like this analysis as you have looked at the song in depth, I particularly like your view on the ‘mine is the heart and the salt of the soul’ part of the song as it conveys your personal approach to the message from the speaker :)
ReplyDeleteGood close analysis of the metaphors. Ciara's point would be juxtaposition or antithesis. You definitely need more terminology to support your interpretations. Consider the GRAPE more and be explicit about how it seems that the producer is representing the implied writer.
ReplyDelete